I am returning here to a subject I covered over ten years ago, the gardens of the kings of Assyria, because I have been to see the British Museum's exhibition, 'I am Ashurbanipal'. I ended my previous post by referring to a relief dated 645 which shows King Ashurbanipal and his Queen in the
royal park in Nineveh, dining under an arbour of grape vines, with the decapitated head of the conquered
king of the Elamites hanging from a nearby tree. This scene is on show in the current exhibition, mounted with other smaller ones to show how a complete wall might have looked. You can see this in my photograph above, which I think also gives an indicates of how wonderfully well lit everything is. The garden landscape in which Ashurbanipal is seen drinking and listening to music contains alternating pine and fruit-bearing date palms, perhaps symbols of Assyria and Babylonia respectively. And in the foliage, a bird goes after a locust - in his annals, Ashurbanipal likened the Elamites to a swarm of locusts.
This second photograph shows the royal park created by Ashurbanipal's grandfather Sennacherib, which I also mentioned in my earlier post. In the new exhibition, coloured light is projected onto this relief, picking out the irrigation channels and trees. You can see the effect in a gif at the British Museum blog site. I will quote here what this site has to say about the landscape:
'The gardens at Nineveh were irrigated by an immense canal network
built by Ashurbanipal’s grandfather, Sennacherib. He brought water to
the city over a great distance using channels and aqueducts to create a
year-round oasis of all types of flora. The canals stretched over 50km into the mountains, and Sennacherib
boasted about the engineering technology he used. A monumental aqueduct
crossing the valley at Jewan, which you can still see the remains of
today, was made of over 2 million stones and waterproof cement. The
aqueduct was constructed over 500 years before the Romans started
building their aqueducts, and was inscribed with the following words: "Sennacherib king of the world king of Assyria. Over a great distance I
had a watercourse directed to the environs of Nineveh, joining together
the waters… Over steep-sided valleys I spanned an aqueduct of white
limestone blocks, I made those waters flow over it."
Since I wrote my last blog post on the gardens at Nineveh, it has been argued that they were in fact 'the real Hanging Gardens of Babylon'. Archaeologist Stephanie Dalley first formulated this theory in 1992 and then published a book with new research in 2013. A Channel 4 documentary was made and her new evidence was widely reported in the news. It would obviously be helpful to do some more digging, but the site of Nineveh, around Mosul, has been too dangerous to excavate. Dalley was quoted in 2013 as saying she thought it unlikely that excavations would be possible in her lifetime. A year later, Daesh overran the area and, as Jonathan Jones says in his review of this exhibition, 'they smashed antiquities in the Mosul Museum and set about demolishing Nineveh itself.' It is sad to think how much can change in the course of a few years, but at least these remarkable artifacts remain to give us, amongst much else, an idea of the gardens created by the kings of Assyria.
My post yesterday was about a nineteenth century French-speaking Swiss writer from Geneva; this one is about an eighteenth century German-speaking Swiss poet from Zurich. However, as can be seen above, Salomon Gessner (1730-88) was also a visual artist. Here is a snatch of his poetry, describing autumn. It is taken from an 1809 translation of Gessner's Idylls (1756-72). According to the Encyclopedia Britannica, 'his pastorals were translated into 20 languages, including Welsh, Latin,
and Hebrew. The English translation ran through many editions and was
admired by the Romantic writers Sir Walter Scott, Lord Byron, and Wordsworth.' However, I see from Wikipedia that 'The New International Encyclopædia
(1905) finds his writing “insipidly sweet and monotonously melodious,”
and attributes Gessner's popularity to the taste of a generation nursed
on Rousseau.'
O'er every vine of gold and purple hue
The sun its animating lustre threw;
And every curling branch, whose friendly shade
Waved o'er his cot, beneath the zephyr play’d.
Clear was the sky, o'er all the valley's bed
The low-land vapours like a lake were spread;
Amidst whose floating surface lightly rear'd
The mountain tops, like little isles appear'd;
Where smoaking huts and fruitful groves were seen
In autumn's richest vest of gold and green.
Salomon Gessner, Pastoral landscape with two women and a boy
playing a flute in front of a herm of Pan, 1787
Gessner was on my mind today as I saw the painting above in the British Museum. It was in the Prints and Drawings room, in a display of art linked to the sketch by Joseph Anton Koch they recently purchased from the Brian Sewell estate (see my post on it last year). Gessner's painting was the basis for an 1805 etching by another artist I have discussed here before, Carl Wilhelm Kolbe. The British Museum also owns an etching by Kolbe of the memorial to Gessner which stands in Zurich's Platspitz Park. In it, 'a well-dressed couple and child looking at Gessner's tomb in the form of
a Greek memorial with a low relief sculpture, set behind a railing in
woodland.'
Carl Wilhelm Kolbe, The Monument to Salomon Gessner in Zurich, c. 1807
In their current exhibition, the British Museum curators have put Gessner's Pastoral Landscape on show next to a different memorial to Gessner, this one by Johann Heinrich Bleuler. The etching was published in the year of Gessner's death and shows a memorial to him situated by a lake. Was it imaginary, like Caspar David Friedrich's proposal for a monument to Goethe? If not, is there still something resembling this at Lake Klöntal, a permanent presence of a landscape painter in the landscape he painted? Yes, it would seem there is, according to the local tourism website and you can do a nice walk to it. They describe the origin of the inscription thus: 'Sie wurde ihm von zwei Verehrern gewidmet, die sich 1788 zur Einweihung des Gedenksteins mit Tränen in den Augen um den Hals fielen und küssten.' ('It was dedicated to him by two devotees who fell around the neck and kissed each other in 1788 with tears in their eyes for the inauguration of the memorial stone' - Google Translate). The writing looks quite amateurish and crudely done, but clearly those admirers meant well.
Johann Heinrich Bleuler, Commemorative stone in memory of Salomon Gessner,
'Any landscape is a condition of the spirit.' -
Henri-Frédéric Amiel
This is one of those quotes about landscape you come across in a diverse range of books. It is also available in tweet-friendly images, such as the one below where it is superimposed on a mountain scene. This longer version is from the translation of Amiel's Journal Intime, published in 1885 by the British novelist Mrs. Humphry Ward. The whole book can be found on Project Gutenburg, so I have copied from there below the journal entry where Amiel makes his observation. As can be seen, it was prompted by an autumn day, with leaves on the ground and a few flowers lingering in the garden. The mountains in the distance were the Alps - Lancy is part of Geneva, the city where Amiel was born and died. This entry was written when he was thirty-one. He was a poet and a philosopher but this journal only appeared posthumously. 'It reveals,' according to the Encyclopedia Bitannica, 'a sensitive man of great intellectual ability, struggling for values against the skepticism of the age. Widely translated, it gained Amiel lasting fame.'
October 31, 1852. (Lancy.)—Walked for half an hour in the garden. A
fine rain was falling, and the landscape was that of autumn. The sky was
hung with various shades of gray, and mists hovered about the distant
mountains, a melancholy nature. The leaves were falling on all sides like
the last illusions of youth under the tears of irremediable grief. A brood
of chattering birds were chasing each other through the Shrubberies, and
playing games among the branches, like a knot of hiding schoolboys. The
ground strewn with leaves, brown, yellow, and reddish; the trees
half-stripped, some more, some less, and decked in ragged splendors of
dark-red, scarlet, and yellow; the reddening shrubs and plantations; a few
flowers still lingering behind, roses, nasturtiums, dahlias, shedding
their petals round them; the bare fields, the thinned hedges; and the fir,
the only green thing left, vigorous and stoical, like eternal youth
braving decay; all these innumerable and marvelous symbols which forms
colors, plants, and living beings, the earth and the sky, yield at all
times to the eye which has learned to look for them, charmed and
enthralled me. I wielded a poetic wand, and had but to touch a phenomenon
to make it render up to me its moral significance. Every landscape is, as
it were, a state of the soul, and whoever penetrates into both is
astonished to find how much likeness there is in each detail. True poetry
is truer than science, because it is synthetic, and seizes at once what
the combination of all the sciences is able at most to attain as a final
result. The soul of nature is divined by the poet; the man of science,
only serves to accumulate materials for its demonstration.
Ferdinand Hodler, Lake Geneva with the Savoy Alps, 1907
Mrs Ward's translation of Amiel's Journal was reviewed and praised by the great Victorian critic, Walter Pater. He quotes Amiel's statement about landscape and the soul in this review (which can be read online). He also observes that although 'in Switzerland it is easy to be pleased with scenery', there are passages of natural description in Amiel that 'rise to real distinction.' He gives three examples, on the effects of fog, frost and rain, and I will close here by quoting the last of these:
August 22, 1873. (Scheveningen).—The weather is rainy, the
whole atmosphere gray; it is a time favorable to thought and meditation. I
have a liking for such days as these; they revive one’s converse with
one’s self and make it possible to live the inner life; they are quiet and
peaceful, like a song in a minor key. We are nothing but thought, but we
feel our life to its very center. Our very sensations turn to reverie. It
is a strange state of mind; it is like those silences in worship which are
not the empty moments of devotion, but the full moments, and which are so
because at such times the soul, instead of being polarized, dispersed,
localized, in a single impression or thought, feels her own totality and
is conscious of herself.
Vincent Van Gogh, Scheveningen Beach in Stormy Weather, 1882
'A lot of my paintings are anonymous backdrops for the drama of words. In a way, they're words in front of the old Paramount Studios mountain. You don't have to have a mountain back there - you could have a landscape, a farm. I have background, foreground. It's so simple. And the backgrounds are of no particular character. They're just meant to support the drama, like the Hollywood sign being held up by sticks.' - Ed Ruscha interviewed in Shift magazine, 1988.
I've been reading Richard D. Marshall's monograph on Ed Ruscha and what comes over repeatedly is his very postmodern, conceptual insistence that there is nothing very significant about the content of his paintings - backgrounds and foregrounds, images and texts are often arbitrary or deliberately chosen to subvert any obvious interpretation. In this quote he is talking about the paintings he has done of words and mountains - I can't reproduce one for copyright reasons but you can see above in low res the results of a google image search for "Ed Ruscha mountain". In these paintings, the mountains dominate the visual field and yet Ruscha's insistence that they are nothing more than a background returns landscape to its Renaissance function as parergon, secondary to the painting's actual subject matter.
The original Paramount mountain, used from 1917 to 1967
Mention of the Paramount mountain made me look it up on Wikipedia. The article's authors make this corporate logo's origins and meaning sound like an intriguing mystery:
'Legend has it that the mountain is based on a doodle made by W. W. Hodkinson during a meeting with Adolph Zukor. It is said to be based on the memories of his childhood in Utah. Some claim that Utah's Ben Lomond is the mountain Hodkinson doodled, and that Peru's Artesonraju is the mountain in the live-action logo, while others claim that the Italian side of Monviso inspired the logo. Some editions of the logo bear a striking resemblance to the Pfeifferhorn, another Wasatch Range peak, and to the Matterhorn on the border between Switzerland and Italy.'
The twenty-four stars on the logo referred to the actors originally under contract at Paramount in 1916. Logos generally have to be simple but because this one is shown on a movie screen it can be very detailed - modern versions have tended to resemble nineteenth century landscape paintings. And of course the actual logo you see at the cinema now is animated - I've included a clip of the 100th anniversary version below.
In the quote above Ed Ruscha mentions another, different form of Hollywood landscape art - the famous old sign itself. Erected in 1923, to advertise "HOLLYWOODLAND", a new segregated, whites-only housing
development in the hills above the LA, it was originally only meant to stay up for a year, but soon came to be seen as a popular landmark and symbol of the home of cinema. It was renovated in 1949 (losing the 'LAND') and again in 1978. Wikipedia will tell you about some of the ways it has been altered, imitated and spoofed over the years, although I see that their 'In Popular Culture' section has a stern note from the editors saying 'this section appears to contain trivial, minor, or unrelated references...' Perhaps someone should put a mention of Ed Ruscha in there - he painted several versions of the Hollywood sign in 1968 and returned to the subject again in 1977, showing the letters in reverse as The Back of Hollywood. Here's another Ruscha quote, from an interview in 1984.
'The Hollywood sign is actually a landscape in a sense. It's a real thing and my view of it was really a conservative interpretation of something that exists, so it almost isn't a word in a woay - it's a structure. It's a phenomenon or something.'
I think this ilustrates how difficult it is to define this sign, let alone an oil
painting of it that exists within a long sequence of works whose
subject is nothing but painted words.
I thought it was time to bring back my regular surveys of 'landscape music', having had a couple of years off. The last one I did was in 2015 - it contains links to the earlier ones, or you can just check back through my old December posts. I should apologise for some dead links in my previous surveys, as videos and tracks have been moved or taken down over the years. Looking back I see there's now a missing video in a post I wrote back in 2010 about Toshiya Tsunoda, the Japanese sound artist. He's the first of my picks for 2018, with the album Wovenland, a collaboration with Taku Unami (the title refers to the way their separate field recordings are woven together). Reviewing it in Wire Magazine, Derek Walmsley thought this 'one of the most original and startling recording projects in recent years.'
One of the albums I missed by not doing this in 2016 was 3hattrio's Solitaire, inspired by Edward Abbey’s nature writing classic, Desert Solitaire (1968). Abbey, author of The Monkey Wrench Gang, based this, his first non-fiction book, on the time he spent as a park ranger at Arches National Monument. 3hattrio say they play 'American desert music':
'Their aim is to create a new music which responds to the
natural world of their sacred homeland near Zion National Park in Utah.
They also strive to acknowledge the cultural traditions of generations
of people who have worked and lived on the deserts of the American
southwest. The subject matter of the songs is often desert oriented,
sometimes not. Mostly, they express the desert experientially from a
daily-ness of watching light off distant mesas and hearing the way sound
plays off sheer sandstone cliffs. Then they play music. They don’t
over-think it.'
Their new release is Lord Of The Desert andincludes tracks called 'Night Sky', 'Skeleton Tree' and 'Dust Devil' (see video clip below).
My earlier round-ups always featured music from Touch and their most recent release is relevant - Howlround's The Debatable Lands. This was inspired by the border region in Cumbria which Graham Robb wrote about in his latest book (quite interesting, but not as rewarding a read as I was expecting). Another liminal space was the source for Jana Winderen's Spring Bloom in the Marginal Ice Zone, originally a sound installation for the 2017 Sonic Acts Festival:
'The marginal ice zone is the dynamic border between the open sea and the
sea ice, which is ecologically extremely vulnerable. The phytoplankton
present in the sea produces half of the oxygen on the planet. During
spring, this zone is the most important CO2 sink in our biosphere. In Spring Bloom in the Marginal Ice Zone
the sounds of the living creatures become a voice in the current
political debate concerning the official definition of the location of
the ice edge.'
I'm listening to the album now as I write this, streaming from Jana Winderen's bandcamp page.
In my round-up for 2012 I featured Erland Cooper's Orkney Symphony. In March this year he released Solan Goose, its tracks named after the Orcadian words for seabirds (the solan goose is a northern gannet). He also released Murmeration, with a Norman Ackroyd picture on the cover (incidentally, Ackroyd's daughter Poppy is a Brighton-based composer, whose work sometimes references landscape themes and uses field recordings). Erland Cooper is planning a third record in this vein, as he explained in an interview for The Island Review, which will explore 'our relationship and respect for the sea: how it surrounds the community
and the landscape; how it supports the greatest ecosystem of all.' Together these albums are inspired by the words of the poet George Mackay Brown. “The essence of Orkney's magic is silence, loneliness and the deep marvellous rhythms of sea and land, darkness and light.”
Stuart Hyatt's Metaphonics: The Complete Field Works Recordings comprises 7 LPs and a book, based around his own field recordings but incorporating collaborations from around forty other artists. The YouTube clip below presents a track from the album Pogue's Run - 'from its source, through the city, into a mysterious three-mile
underground tunnel, and finally to the White River, Pogue’s Run
represents the ongoing tension between nature and civilization.' I enjoyed seeing field recordists filmed as if they were in a pop video, although as this goes on and they reach the underground river, it more closely resembles scenes a scene from a science fiction film. There is an interview with Hyatt at the online art/science magazineCLOT. He quotes from an essay by Yiorgis Sakellariou in the Metaphonics book, which views field recording as "an alchemical
practice, a transformation of perception of both recordist and
environment. A recording location is not simply a geographically framed
scenery, but more importantly, a place of inquiry, experimentation, and
wonder."
I will stick there at five main recommendations, but here, briefly, are a few other albums from 2018 that reflect landscape in different ways. Further suggestions in the comments below would be welcome.
Grouper's Grid of Points, written by Liz Harris during a residency in Ucross, Wyoming. One of its tracks is inspired by Zabriskie Point, a film I wrote about here in May.
Richard Skelton's Front Variations subjected sine waves 'to increasing amounts of feedback in
order to simulate the so-called ice-albedo feedback mechanism.
This is the process whereby the action of melting glaciers reduces the
global surface area of ice, thereby reducing the amount of solar
radiation that glaciers reflect, which in turn increases global
temperatures and causes further glacial melting.'
Laurie Anderson's Landfall is a cycle of songs about Hurricane Sandy - a recording was released this year with the Kronos Quartet. Tracks include 'Wind Whistles Through the Dark City,' 'The Water Rises' and 'Our Street is a Black River'...
Daniel Bachman's guitar in The Morning Star is set against a background of field recordings. It continues a sequence of 'Songs for the Setting Sun' that he began on the 2015 album River (which was featured on my 2015 round-up).
Jim Ghedi's A Hymn For Ancient Land, was a bit too pastoral for the Quietus reviewer: 'only on ‘Phoenix Works’, a song dealing with the decline of traditional
industries in the north, does he explicitly deal with darkness. This,
coupled with the dense, meandering tonalities of ‘Fortingall Yew’, saves
the album from being a landscape painting.'
According to The Quietus, the album of the year was Gazelle Twin's Pastoral, which 'picks away at the bucolic, Constable-generated image of English countryside like a fetid scab.' Gazelle Twin is Brighton-based electonic musician Elizabeth Bernholz, whose previous project was based on J. G. Ballard's last novel Kingdom Come.
Finally, I will conclude here not with an album, but with an app. Numero Group's 'Environments collects the entire historic record series by master sound
engineer Irv Teibel into one easy to use package for the iPhone and
iPad' (it costs £2.99). If you're not familiar with Irv Teibel's 1970s psychoacoustic nature recordings, there's a good article about him at Pitchfork. Aquarium Drunkarddescribed the new app as 'an ingenious re-contextualization of this retro-futurist
“gebrauchtsmusik” that recapitulates the series’ initial novelty.
However captivating Teibel’s tale, the Environments app
now illuminates an anthropocene landscape where 'Dusk in the Okefenokee
Swamp' and a 'Summer Cornfield' are mediated by an inescapable layer of
sleek, fabricated hardware and playfully nostalgic software.'
George Lambert, Box Hill with Dorking in the Distance, 1733
Images: Wikimedia Commons
Yale University's British Art Studies is a completely open access journal and its Autumn issue is dedicated to 'Landscape Now'. In addition to various articles, including the Tim Barringer piece I referred to earlier this month, there is a 'Conversation Piece' coordinated by Alexandra Harris. She refers to the current popularity of books about nature, but suggests that 'while readers are offered new ideas about landscape
writing at every festival (several festivals are devoted to the subject)
and with every Amazon click and with each week’s Caught by the River newsletter, it can be harder to get much purchase on developments in
contemporary visual arts and art history. Work by art historians is not
always being brought to the common table...' Unsurprisingly (given what I wite about here), agree with this. She also gives an insight into what she has been researching recently (I have written about here before about her previous books on landscape and culture, Weatherlandand Romantic Moderns).
I've been trying in my own research to get closer to an
understanding of what places have looked like to different kinds of
people living in them. I want to find evidence for what “views” have
looked like to people, other than the makers and consumers of landscape
art. It’s hard: I’ve been reading for two years—parish registers, local
histories, antiquarian guides, court proceedings, wills and inventories,
tithe maps, a very occasional diary; I’ve been wondering at the skill
and sensitivity of local historians like Margaret Spufford and many who
followed her lead—yet still I’m baffled by the difficulty of reaching
the landscape feelings of the past. [...] Whether we are reaching back to life before (or without access to)
the grammars of Western landscape painting, or looking again at
Lambert, Wootton, and Wilson, or thinking about contemporary artists, it
may be fruitful to reunite landscape with local knowledge and local
people, from the airy prospects to make out local habitations and names.
John Wootton, A Fox Hunt, c. 1735
Several responses follow Alexandra Harris's introduction, some more informative than others. Rachel Hewitt for example, tells us that at present 'there is important work being done, by Hayley Flynn among
others, on [William] Blake’s interactions with, and subversions of, the
eighteenth-century British landscape tradition' (I wonder if this new scholarship will surface in the Tate's Blake exhibition, scheduled for autumn next year). Emily Hayes writes about the influence of the Royal Geographical Society's magic lantern lectures, including those by Vaughan Cornish, a 'chemist turned geographer' who specialised in the study of waves, before turning later 'towards eugenics and landscape heritage activism'. The intention is that this Conversation 'will develop as more respondents enter the debate. Readers can also join in by adding a response at the bottom of the page.' There are no responses yet - I hope there will be, but I've learnt here that in the age of Twitter you can't really expect people to go to the trouble of adding written comments.
Vaughan Cornish, Breaker and Bores on a Flat Shore, 1910
I will conclude here by pointing you to three other articles in the journal, each about landscape artists I have discussed here before.
Anna Reid's piece, 'Paul Nash's Geological Enigma', reviews the artist's interest in contemporary geophysical research;
Greg Smith takes a fresh look at Thomas Girtin's panorama, The Eidometropolis, drawing on material that has become available only in recent years;
And in 'Liquid Landscapes',
Stephen Daniels juxtaposes a series of pond photographs by Jem Southam
with Constable's depiction of Branch Hill Pond in his pictures of
Hampstead Heath.
John Constable, Hampstead Heath, with Pond and Bathers, 1821
I have been reading Shane McCausland's scholarly study, Zhao Mengfu: Calligraphy and Painting for Khubilai's China, which focuses not just on Zhao's paintings, but on the colophons added to them over the years by writers wishing to comment on the artist and his work. These are not usually visible in reproductions - the photograph of Water Village above shows only the annotations and seals visible on the composition itself. Below I've photographed the colophons for Water Village reproduced in McCausland's book (pp242-3). A footnote lists the authors of these - most were writing soon after the painting was finished but others date from the late Ming Dynasty. It would be natural to consider these as critical texts rather than works of landscape art themselves. But the fact that these colophons were composed in verse and written in beautiful calligraphy mean that they form a kind of secondary landscape art themselves. Zhao Mengfu himself was a renowned calligrapher and his own artistry can therefore be seen in colophons he added to other scrolls of paintings or poetry.
Water Village has a pictorial realism that impressed its colophon writers - one said you could almost forget it is actually a picture. The handscroll 'begins' at the far right with a vertical title, leading the eye down to a bluff with bushes sprouting from it (see below). McCausland sees this as having a 'liminal role', marking the transition from calligraphy to painting and from surface to illusionistic space. From there the eye can explore the low-lying landscape, arranged in an X-shape and centred on a tiny bridge. There are few people, just a few isolated huts. Zhao Menfu himself wrote that this subject captured the ideal hermitage, a place of scholarly retreat. Other colophon writers were reminded of Wang Wei, the great landscape poet and painter who wrote about his own retirement from the world in the Wang River Sequence.
The most intrusive colophons to Water Village were added by the Qianlong Emperor, who reigned over China for much of the eighteenth
century. He added two seals and a poem to the painting itself. In one of the first posts on this blog I wrote about the way the emperor filled his own painting of Mount Pan with no less than thirty-four later descriptions. He also added a colophon to Zhao Mengfu's Autumn Colours on the Qiao and Hua Mountains (1296) pointing out an error in the artist's geography(this painting is discussed in an earlier post). For Water Village, he wrote a colophon referring to Qu Yuan, an early Chinese poet I wrote about here in March, who drowned himself after being wrongly banished from court. The emperor read this act as a gesture of loyalty, perhaps reflecting his own anxieties as a Manchu ruler of the Chinese. He also described taking the painting with him on a visit to the Eastern Mountains, where Water Village is set (somewhere near Sonjiang). 'In surveying the scene,' McCausland writes, 'the emperor drained this place and its depiction of any symbolism as a private refuge of the literati from the affairs of state and government.'
Sauvages de la Mer Pacifique wallpaper, before 1829
A new article in British Art Studies by Tim Barringer provides a history of recent trends in landscape art history. In this century, he explains, there has been a strong focus on art and empire, influenced by Edward Said’s Orientalism,
and analysis of paintings made far from Europe, which reveal 'the impediments offered to the
totalizing “colonial picturesque” by local geographies'. He then describes a recent artwork that I was looking at only this weekend:
'The
work of contemporary indigenous artists increasingly offers critical
reflections on the continuing power of landscape as a contested space
open to multiple interpretations, and as a site of historical and
contemporary violence. Lisa Reihana’s in Pursuit of Venus [infected], (2015–2017), on display at the time of publication in the exhibition Oceaniaat the Royal Academy of Arts in London, responds to the historical provocation of Les Sauvages de la Mer Pacifique,
a scenic coloured wallpaper in twenty panels, created in 1804 by Joseph
Dufour on the basis of imagery from the Pacific voyages of James Cook (Les Voyages du Capitaine Cook was proposed as an alternative title for the paper).
Reihana’s panoramic video spanning 26 metres embraces the “monarch of
all I survey” viewpoint of the painted panoramas of the late eighteenth
century, but inserts speaking, singing, and moving figures to contest
the silent, stereotypical representations of indigenous people in
eighteenth- and nineteenth-century sources.'
At the Royal Academy, you encounter this video panorama towards the end of the exhibition and I found it quite hard to drag myself away. Figures like Captain Cook, Joseph Banks and Chief Kalani'opu'u are seen in various moving tableaux as the viewpoint pans steadily round. The original wallpaper was not on display in the exhibition (the National Gallery of Australia has an example) - perhaps it would have been out of place among so many beautiful objects from the islands. In an interview in the Guardian, Lisa Reihana describes its design as
'“a concoction, a fabulation invented in someone else’s elsewhere”. The
greenery, for example, was transplanted not from Polynesia but from
South America, which Jean Gabriel Charvet, the Frenchman who designed
the wallpaper, had recently visited. Similarly, the idealised,
pale-skinned locals are dressed in neoclassical costumes inspired more
by what had recently been dug up at Pompeii than by anything from Hawaii
or Tahiti.'
In Pursuit of Venus was previously shown at the Venice Biennale and has its own website (it even has an Instagram feed, although there are no posts on it yet...) Tim Marlow, the RA Director, calls it 'stupendous' in an interview with Lisa Reihana, viewable on the RA's site. Excellent as it is, there are many more wonders in the show which I could mention but which go beyond the remit of this blog, from the Brancusi-like male deity sculpture tino aitu to a Tobi Island necklace of sea-urchin spines. As Jenny Uglow wrote in her review, 'Oceania is a powerful demonstration of art’s capacity to fight the
tide of loss, honoring tradition, reclaiming places, histories, and
identities, and opening the way to the future.'
One of the most renowned Buster Keaton stunts involves him getting the better of a landscape feature. Our Hospitality (1923) has scenes filmed at California's Truckee River and when I first saw it I thought the waterfall scene (above) was filmed at a real location. In reality the whole waterfall was constructed on a Hollywood backlot, as is explained (with photographs) on the excellent Silent Locations website. I will quote here what John Bengtson says there:
During the climax of OurHospitality, Buster rescues his
girlfriend, played by his first wife Natalie Talmadge, from sweeping
over the brink of a waterfall, by swinging like a pendulum from a rope
tied to a log jammed in the rocks, grabbing her just as she starts to
fall. Buster’s waterfall stunt set was built astride the [...] T-shaped concrete pool (or plunge as they were called back then) that
stood on the Robert Brunton Studio backlot just north of Melrose Avenue,
now part of the current-day Paramount Studios lot.
In Sherlock Jr. (1924), Keaton, a projectionist, falls asleep and walks in his dream into the motion picture he is showing. We then see him in a sequence of cuts that seamlessly position Keaton in different landscapes: a rocky promontory (below), a jungle, a beach, a rock in the sea. This was done using surveying instruments to position him at precisely the right place in each setting. From the rock in the sea, Keaton dives into the water and lands in a park, then leans against a tree and finds himself in a garden, after which the main story of this film-within-a-film begins, with the humble projectionist somehow transformed into a Sherlock Holmes style detective.
Buster Keaton in Sherlock Jr. (1924)
The bridge scene in The General (1926)
Thinking about Keaton in relation to this blog, it occurs to me that his most spectacular film stunt - building a bridge and wrecking a real train for The General (1926) - had a similar level of ambition to the works of land artists like Christo and Jeanne Claude. Apparently,
bits of Keaton's railtrack can still be seen at the bottom of Row River
at low tide. But if I had to choose my favourite example of Buster Keaton
'landscape art' it would be the moment in The Scarecrow (1920) when he manages to cross a river without getting his feet wet, by walking across it on his hands.
I will conclude here by recommending again the website SilentLocations.com, which is still posting fascinating information on Keaton and other silent movie stars. Browsing through it I came across the photograph below: if Richard Long had been working in the 1920s he might have looked like Charlie Chaplin in this field. In fact, this circle is the trace of the departing circus, which is just packing up and leaving The Little Tramp behind. Detective work by Bengtson and other enthusiasts has identified the location for this scene and even a surviving tree that was there when the film was made. 'Just as there are trees that remain today having witnessed the making of The Birth of A Nation, a giant old oak tree in Glendale, appearing onscreen at left, witnessed the concluding scenes from The Circus.'
I now have just over a month left of my project to tweet a landscape a day for 2018. It is never possible to predict how many 'likes' these will get - obviously I feel they're all interesting or beautiful in one way or another. Possibly my least popular one this year, with just two 'likes' (one of which came from my mother!) was a Robert S. Duncanson landscape painting showing Vesuvius and Pompeii. This, despite the fact I posted it with the hashtag #BlackHistoryMonth... Clearly if anyone was looking for this hashtag during that particular month, they were not interested in my Duncanson painting. He may have been the first prominent African-American landscape artist, but his style of painting is perhaps too unfashionable to excite much buzz on social media. But his paintings are interesting in their own right - in my tweet I said that "in this view of Pompeii I particularly like that painting-within-a-painting, a large fresco resembling an outdoor cinema."
Robert S. Duncanson was born in 1821 in the state of New York. His grandfather was a freed slave from Virginia and his father lived there, until growing opposition to freed black men persuaded him to move north. The family settled in Michigan and then, as a young man, Robert Duncanson taught himself painting in Cincinnati, 'the Athens of the West'. His first significant landscape painting, Cliff Mine, Lake Superior (1848) was acquired by Charles Avery, one of several abolitionist patrons who bought his work. In 1853 he visited Europe and a year later he collaborated with the prominent African-American photographer James Presley Ball on an anti-slavery panoramic painting, Mammoth Pictorial Tour of the United States Comprising Views of the African Slave Trade. When the Civil War began, he moved to Canada and then Britain, where he was particularly impressed by the Scottish Highlands. He returned to America and died at the age of just 51, possibly due to the effects of lead poisoning. The view of Vesuvius and Pompeii is thus a late work, inspired by his travels almost twenty years earlier.
Robert S. Duncanson, Blue Hole, Flood Waters, Little Miami River, 1851
Until this year, Duncanson did not have a tombstone. However, it was good to come upon a report in the Detroit Free Press (via a JStor article last week), explaining that this is about to change.
'For more than a century, his body has remained in Monroe, about 40
miles south of Detroit, with nothing but grass growing over his grave.
Now, a small foundation marks the site of his burial awaiting the
arrival of a tombstone.
“No one has asked about him — not in my lifetime,” said
Michael Huggins, 55, the manager of the Historic Woodland Cemetery for
the past two decades, and the person who helped find the exact location
of Duncanson’s burial plot.
[... Now] nearly a century and a half later, Monroe resident Dora Kelley is looking to rewrite a chapter of Duncanson’s life. Kelley worked with LeClair Monuments in Lambertville to design a
sleek black granite tombstone for Duncanson complete with his full name,
the year of his death and an etched version of his Ellen’s Isle painting from the DIA’s collection. Kelley also chose a quote from the late artist to grace
the monument, which speaks to Duncanson’s unprecedented position as a
freeborn artist in the era of slavery: “I have no color on the brain;
all I have on the brain is paint.”
Robert S. Duncanson, Ellen's Isle, Loch Katrine, 1871
Land Makar is a half hour film by Margaret Tait, whose centenary is being celebrated this year. Here is a brief description from the BFI's website, where it is listed as one of '10 films that defined Tait’s filmmaking style.'
'Starting with harvest, Land Makar
(‘makar’ is a Scottish word for poet) is divided into seasons. The main
character, Tait’s farming neighbour Mary Graham Sinclair, is filmed
driving a tractor on the fields of an Orkney croft, going about her
daily activity on the land and talking about “the beauty of a work day”.
Tait started filming this place in 1977, observing the hard labour and
activities that define the land. With Sinclair, she also explores the
rarely told story of women and land labour.'
Maragaret Tait was a doctor-poet (like William Carlos Williams) as well as a film maker. In a recent piece about Land Makar, for Sight and Sound, Becca Voelcker quotes the poem 'Now' in which Tait advises the reader to take poetry quickly,
'without water'.
'For Tait, poems are as ephemeral as wildflowers. Prescribing a quickness of mind and body, like a capsule 'without water', the poem ends with urgency: 'Tomorrow they'll be something else.' The poem, like Land Makar, imagines place as a cluster of transforming elements. For Tait, landscape is a continuing process.'
I went to see Land Makar last week - it was part of the BFI season 'Rhythm and Poetry: The Films of Margaret Tait'. Watching Sinclair on her tractor, scything long grass and climbing onto a compost heap, it was impossible not to admire her energy - all the physical effort put into this stretch of land. At one point she recalls helping some swans build their nests (I caught the drift of this, but found the Orcadian dialect impossible to follow exactly). Voelcker quotes another poem, 'The Scale of things', where Tait describes 'all the tiny plants
and flowers / Which, together interlaced and inter-related, / Make the
fine springing turf which people and animals / walk on.' Crofters and
poets (and swans) are makers' whose collective labour sustains the
land.'
Land Makar was shown at the NFT with The Drift Back (1956), a ten minute 'offical' documentary on the return of some families to Orkney, and The Big Sheep (1966), a 41 minute essay film concerning the landscape of East Sutherland, with striking music and sound effects. Here is Margaret Tait's own description of The Big Sheep:
"A picture of East Sutherland in 1966.
Tourists come north, coach-load after coach-load; and here is the
countryside they come to see, dotted with sheep continually nibbling at
grass and whin. Then the lamb sales, an open-air auction, after which
the lambs are carried south, float after float. Vote, vote, vote, on the
posters for a general election, but "Why don't you get your sheep to
go and fight for you ? " echoes a voice from the past, at the sight of a
recruiting poster at the local Drill Hall. In the glens stand stand
roofless houses, as well as more ancient (prehistoric) remains, beside
the Highland river.
PART TWO and the seaboard life of today; the
railway line along the very edge of that marvellous strip of coast,
school sports near the salmon river, crofter's fields where the Cheviot
sheep now figure, local buses, electricity, the Highland Games and
pibroch contest. Then John N MacAskill plays the "Lament for Donald of
Laggan", while a small burn tumbles endlessly seaward, sometimes
quietly, sometimes spate, and the film searches the same few yards of it
again and again, watching along with the coalman who stands listening
to the sound of it as if he could listen to it for ever."
It was that final sequence that I found most moving, with the pibroch constantly changing as it flowed from the pipes, before giving way to the natural music of the river.
I have been reading J. D. Frodsham's translations, The Collected Poems of Li He, recently reissued by Calligrams. If you are not familiar with Li He (790-816), here's how he's described in the blurb:
Li He is the bad-boy poet of the late Tang dynasty. He began writing at
the age of seven and died at twenty-six from alcoholism or, according
to a later commentator, “sexual dissipation,” or both. An obscure and
unsuccessful relative of the imperial family, he would set out at dawn
on horseback, pause, write a poem, and toss the paper away. A servant
boy followed him to collect these scraps in a tapestry bag.
The book is wonderfully well-furnished with notes and an extensive introduction. There is a short analysis of Li He's use of colour, similar to what I wrote about recently in relation to Georg Trakl (1887-1914). Despite living 1,100 years and over 7000 km apart, Li He and Trakl had a lot in common. I mentioned Trakl's use of black - 'black decay, black snow, black wind, black waters, black silence'. For Li He, there was white, which in China is associated with mourning and misfortune. 'Even in the West,
psychologists tend to associate a strong liking for white with psychic
abnormality ... He's landscapes, drenched in this white radiance, shine
with an unearthly pallor.'
Li He in Wanxiaotang Zhuzhuang Huazhuan (1743)
Frodsham writes that Li He 'was haunted by the mystery of whiteness as another great, poet, Lorca, was haunted by the spell of green.' This is a reference to Lorca's 'Romance Sonambulo' which begins 'Verde que te quiero verde', 'Green, how I want you green.' Start looking for doomed poets who were obsessed with colour and you will quickly encounter other cases. Dylan Thomas, for example, uses green 46 times in his poetry, black 39 and white 37. This information comes from a 1972 article comparing Thomas and Lorca's use of green. 'Fern Hill' is the Thomas poem most infused with the colour green, where it means youth, innocence, and the hills and fields around a Carmarthenshire farmhouse where the poet went to stay as a boy.
An analysis by Eliot Slater revealed that Shelley and Keats were 'relatively abundent' in their use of colour. However, 'Shelley uses for the greater part straightforward and commonplace words: yellow, blue, snowy, purple, green, grey, white, black, golden, hoary, dun, azure, etc., and very rarely such exotic terms as "moonlight‑coloured". Keats is much freer with such words, and phrases as vermeil, damask, verdurous, Tyrian, rubious‑argent, ruddy gules, volcanian yellow, etc.' Shelley favoured blue and green, Keats used white more than any other colour.
Which brings us back to Li He... J. D. Frodsham provides a table showing that white (bai), ecru (su) and jade-white (yu) appear 172 times in Li He's poetry. After that, comes gold or metal (jin, 73), red (hong, 69), blue-green (ching, 68), emerald (lu, 48), yellow (huang, 45), sapphire (bi, 26) and purple (zi, 25). Frodsham lists of some of the 'white' lines in Li's verse (which is what I did for Trakl, only with blue). For example,
The entire mountain bathed in a white dawn.
A white sky, water like raw silk.
Jade mist on green water / like pennants of white.
And, as Frodsham writes, it is against this pallid background that 'the other colours burn with a brilliant flame...'
A thousand hills of darkest emerald
Smoky yellow mantles the willows
Twilight purple freezes in the dappled sky
I will end here with a longer quote, as these isolated lines cannot do Li He's poems (and Frodsham's translations) justice at all. I think it should be alright to include one whole short poem here, 'Cold up North', which describes ice on the Yellow River (a subject I once wrote a whole post about here). The poem is unusually straightforward for Li He, and requires no particular explanation. In its colours, it moves from the darkness of a winter sky to the jade white of frozen waterfalls.
One quarter lours black while three turn purple,
Ice vaults the Yellow River, fish and dragons die.
Tree-bark three feet thick splits against the grain,
Chariots of a ton or more travel on the river.
Frost-flowers on the grass, big as silver-coins,
No brandished blade could penetrate the sombre sky.
Swirling in a raging sea the flying ice-floes roar,
Soundless hang mountain waterfalls, rainbows of jade.
In Julien Gracq's fluvial revery The Narrow Waters (1976) he recalls the childhood sensation of being drawn down the river Evre by an almost imperceptible current. It was a memory that would provoke intense pleasure when he came to read 'The Domain of Arnheim', a story by Edgar Allan Poe that I discussed here a few years ago, in which the narrator's skiff seems to be pulled along by an invisible force. Then, again, 'years later, Lohengrin's swan moving up- and downstream on the imaginary waterways of the opera scene recalled once again, momentarily, that sensation of an almost troubling happiness.' I too love this image of a boat gliding with no obvious means of propulsion, taking its
passenger to some special destination. It can be found in various legends
associated, like Lohengrin, with King Arthur: indeed the Grail itself is said to have arrived in Britain this way, carried by Joseph of Arimathea in a ship guided by God.
Wang Ximeng, A Thousand Li of Rivers and Mountains (detail), 1113
Later in The Narrow Waters, Gracq returns to the theme of the effortless river journey.
'Only Chinese painting (Song Dynasty landscapes in particular) has been haunted by the humble theme of a solitary rowboat moving through a wooded gorge. Clearly the great charm of such an image derives from the contrast between the sheer physical effort evoked by the steep slopes and the level, incredible ease of the river flowing eternally between peaks: the jubilant feeling born, in the dreamer's consciousness, of the discovery of an effortless solution to contradictions here becomes a fixed reality. Vaulted tree branches beneath which one glides along, branches of rock-loving pines that hang in angles over the water in Chinese drawings, intensify the feeling of calm intoxication and can give way, in a moment - with the whimsy of a ribbon of water ringed by precipices - to a protected intimacy, the alluring fancy of canopies of trees cradling a canal that runs straight into the horizon.'
At the end of the book, Gracq reflects on why he is not tempted to return to the Evre and make this journey again. It is 'not the fear of dispelling the charm of memories. Rather, it's the impossibility of reanimating a dream, or at least of finding again its rhythm which, although devoid of any notion of speed, never ceases to change.'
Flicking through a book my son got out of the library last week called 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die, I came to the year 1982. Bladerunner, E.T, Gandhi are all there of course, but the first 'movie' you come to for that year is Trop Tôt, Trop Tard by Jean-Marie Straub and Daniele Huillet. The half page entry for this film (Too Early, Too Late in English) was written by Jonathan Rosenbaum, who calls it 'one of the best landscape films', making me wonder if perhaps he could write a book called 1001 Landscape Films You Must See Before You Die. His entry in the book is reproduced in full online, so I will quote its description of the film here:
'The first part shows a series of locations in contemporary France,
accompanied by Huillet reading part of a letter Friedrich Engels wrote
to Karl Kautsky describing the impoverished state of French peasants,
and excerpts from the “Notebooks of Grievances” compiled in 1789 by the
village mayors of those same locales in response to plans for further
taxation. The especially fine second section, roughly twice as long,
does the same thing with a more recent Marxist text by Mahmoud Hussein
about Egyptian peasants' resistance to English occupation prior to the
“petit-bourgeois” revolution of Neguib in 1952. Both sections suggest
that the peasants revolted too soon and succeeded too late. One of the
film's formal inspirations is Beethoven's late quartets, and its slow
rhythm is central to the experience it yields; what's remarkable about
Straub and Huillet's beautiful long takes is how their rigorous
attention to both sound and image seems to open up an entire universe,
whether in front of a large urban factory or out on a country road.'
None of the landscape footage in the film is particularly picturesque, it just seems to record the countryside as the filmmakers found it. This unprepossessing muddy track, for example, appears just over an hour into the film, in the Egyptian section. The camera slowly pans across fields to this point and stays motionless for almost five minutes as a few figures pass, going about their business. The view is fixed. You cannot turn around to see what a noise off screen might be or look more closely at something in the foreground. As people slowly approach you are almost forced to wonder what brought them here at this particular moment, about their lives and the lives of everyone around them.
The length, form and sequence of shots in the film seems almost arbitrary, so when this one ends at the point that an aeroplane can be heard overhead, you wonder if you should hear this as a symbol and a reminder that there is nothing 'timeless' in this view, or simply regard it as another chance element of the soundscape. The shot that follows this is another long take, this time from a vehicle travelling along a road. Watching this reminded me of recent experiments in slow television, although these have been much more glossy and set in landscapes with clear visual appeal. The rather grainy 16mm footage of Too Early, Too Late is sometimes reminiscent of Shoah, which I wrote about here last year. Landscape in these films has to convey authenticity, both in the moment of its filming and the political history it has passed through.
In 2011 Staub was interviewed during the Egyptian uprising, which seemed to add another layer of meaning to the film. The opening exchange does not auger well: 'Céline Condorelli: I only have three questions for you.
Jean-Marie Straub: That’s very good, because I don’t have anything to say about this film.' However, Straub does have some interesting things to say, e.g. about the reasons for juxtaposing as 'a diptych' the French and Egyptian footage - 'to compare places that in France look deserted with places that in Egypt are full of life and people.' I will conclude here with three quotes from the interview, pertaining to landscape.
CC: [...] How does one choose the appropriate position for the camera? JMS: That is the least one can do when filming…. You
need to go there and walk around. Walk around a place or a village
three times, and find the right topographic, strategic point. In a way
that one may be able to see something, but without destroying the
mystery of what one sees… but this isn’t specific to this film, this is
the case in all our films.
JMS: [...] There is an element of fiction, but it
comes from the place itself. When you see a donkey passing by chance,
and of course this only happened for one take, pulled with a rope by a
man, with a woman sitting on it… of course this becomes mythological. Things like this cannot be anticipated, and are the gift of chance.
But of course you need to have enough time, margins, and space for
things like that to occur.
CC: But does the topography speak, can it have a voice? JMS: Well cinema is, or should be, the art of space.
Even though a film exists only if that space is able to become time.
But the basic work is space. As Mallarmé said: “Nothing will take place,
but the place.”